Pull-Up vs. Tabbed Nappies: Which is Better for Adults?
Adult incontinence is more common than people think — and managing it well starts with finding the right product. Whether you're caring for an elderly parent, supporting an NDIS participant, or shopping for yourself, one of the biggest decisions you'll make is choosing between pull-up style and tabbed-style adult nappies.
Both serve the same purpose — staying dry, comfortable, and confident — but they’re built differently and designed for different needs. And with so many options on the market (each promising the best absorbency and comfort), it’s easy to feel overwhelmed.
Why Some Adults Prefer Pull-Up Nappies
Pull-up nappies (also called incontinence underwear) are a popular choice for a reason — they’re built for comfort, dignity, and freedom. If you or someone you care for is managing light to moderate incontinence and still fairly mobile, these could be just what you’re looking for.
1. They Feel Like “Normal” Underwear
Let’s face it — the idea of switching to adult nappies can feel daunting. But pull-ups look and feel a lot like your regular undies. No bulky tabs, no plastic crinkle. Just soft, stretchy fabric that slips on and off easily. According to Wellness Briefs, this “everyday feel” is one of the biggest reasons people choose them — especially when they’re adjusting to incontinence for the first time.
2. Great for People Who Still Like Their Independence
Pull-ups are a win for anyone who prefers to handle things on their own. They’re easy to pull up and down — no assistance or lying down needed. If you’re managing your own toileting, or helping someone who can, this small detail makes a big difference.
3. Discreet Under Clothes
Designed to sit snugly against the body, pull-ups are slim and smooth under clothing. No bulky outlines, no shifting during movement. That means more confidence — whether you’re running errands, at work, or heading to a family BBQ.
4. Ideal for Daytime and On-the-Go Use
Pull-ups are especially handy when you’re out and about. They stay put while you move and are easy to change when needed — no wrestling with tabs or trying to get everything aligned in a public bathroom. As Wellness Briefs points out, they’re a great choice for active lifestyles or travel.
5. Designed for Comfort (and Confidence)
Let’s be clear — these aren’t just practical. They’re made to help you feel more like you. Pull-ups support dignity and routine, which is a big deal for anyone navigating continence care. And when your incontinence product makes you feel like yourself again? That’s a win.
Why Tabbed Nappies Might Be the Better Fit (Literally)
Pull-ups aren’t the only option — and for many adults, tabbed nappies (or “adult diapers”) are the better choice. Whether you're supporting someone with limited mobility, managing heavy or overnight incontinence, or simply need more leak protection, tabbed styles bring serious peace of mind.
1. Adjustable Fit for Every Body
Tabbed nappies are all about flexibility. The side tabs let you customise the fit to your body (or your loved one’s) — snug where it needs to be, looser where it doesn’t. That means fewer leaks and more comfort, especially for people who are lying down, in wheelchairs, or have changing waist sizes due to health issues. As NorthShore points out, the adjustability is a huge win for caregivers too.
2. Easier for Carers to Change
If you’re supporting someone who can’t stand or step into pull-ups, tabbed nappies are your MVP. They can be changed without removing clothing from the waist down — which makes things quicker, safer, and more dignified for both the carer and the person being cared for. Nighttime changes or bed-bound care? This is where tabbed designs shine.
3. Maximum Absorbency & Leak Protection
Tabbed nappies generally hold more — full stop. They’re built for moderate to heavy incontinence, which includes overnight use, bowel incontinence, and extended wear. If managing frequent leaks is your top concern, this extra absorbency can make a world of difference.
4. Secure Fit, Even Overnight
Worried about leaks while sleeping or lounging? Tabbed nappies stay in place. With strong side fasteners and higher waist coverage, they’re less likely to shift — even with lots of movement in bed. That means less bedding to wash and more restful nights.
5. Better for Complex Needs
Whether you’re dealing with skin breakdown, mobility challenges, or neurological conditions, tabbed nappies offer more control. You can check the fit easily, adjust it throughout the day, or even add liners for extra protection — all without needing to fully undress the person.
How to Choose Between Pull-Ups and Tabbed Nappies
When it comes to adult incontinence care, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer — and that’s a good thing. Your needs (or your loved one’s) might change day to day, or even hour to hour. So how do you decide which option is best?
Let’s break it down with some practical questions:
How mobile is the person using the nappy?
- More mobile? Pull-ups are usually the go-to. They’re easier to put on and take off independently, much like regular underwear.
- Limited mobility or bed-bound? Tabbed nappies make changing safer and more efficient, especially for carers.
Is this for daytime or overnight use?
- Daytime: Pull-ups are discreet under clothes and offer great protection for light to moderate leakage.
- Overnight or extended wear: Tabbed nappies typically provide higher absorbency and are less likely to leak, especially when lying down.
How heavy is the incontinence?
- Light to moderate bladder leakage: Pull-ups are a solid choice for comfort and convenience.
- Heavy bladder or bowel incontinence: Tabbed nappies win for absorbency, odour control, and leak security.
Are they managing their own care or being supported by a carer?
- Independent users: Pull-ups feel more like underwear and are easier to manage solo.
- Carer-supported users: Tabbed nappies are faster and easier to change, especially when clothing removal isn’t ideal.
Is odour control a priority?
Tabbed nappies often include multi-layered cores and better odour-locking technology, especially in premium brands. Ideal for long wear or social confidence.
Bonus Tip: Try Both!
Many carers and individuals find that having both options on hand offers the best flexibility:
- Pull-ups for active days out or short errands.
- Tabbed nappies for overnight, travel, or rest days when extra support is needed.
Top Pull-Up Nappies for Comfort and Discretion
1. MoliCare Premium Mobile 10 Drops
Why you’ll love it:
This high-absorbency pull-up is designed for full mobility with soft, skin-friendly materials and odour-neutralising technology. It fits like regular underwear but holds up to heavy leakage — great for active lifestyles without compromising protection.
Best for:
Daytime wear, active users with moderate to heavy incontinence, or those who prefer a discreet, underwear-style fit.
2. TENA Pants ProSkin Maxi
Why you’ll love it:
With Dual Absorption Zones and a soft, stretchable waistband, these pull-ups feel gentle against the skin while offering powerful protection. They’re breathable, dermatologically tested, and ideal for long wear.
Best for:
Overnight use or longer outings where reliability, comfort, and skin health matter most.
3. Abena Pants Bariatric
Why you’ll love it:
Designed specifically for larger bodies, these bariatric pull-ups offer generous sizing (153–203 cm waist) with high absorbency and a comfortable, secure fit. A true confidence booster for those who often struggle to find the right size.
Best for:
Bariatric individuals looking for a well-fitting pull-up with excellent leakage protection and comfort.
Top Tabbed Nappies for Maximum Support and Easy Changes
1. TENA Slip ProSkin Maxi
Why you’ll love it:
A classic tab-style design with stretchable side panels and breathable materials that protect fragile skin. It offers a snug fit, high absorbency, and excellent odour control — even for overnight use.
Best for:
Individuals with heavy incontinence or reduced mobility, particularly those who need assistance with changing.
2. TENA Flex ProSkin Maxi
Why you’ll love it:
A unique belt-style nappy that combines the comfort of a wrap with the adjustability of tabs. The hook-and-loop fastening makes changes fast and easy — a favourite among professional carers.
Best for:
Carers supporting individuals who are semi-mobile, or for quick, frequent changes without needing to fully undress.
3. TENA Flex ProSkin Ultima
Why you’ll love it:
Need serious protection? This is the top-tier solution in TENA’s Flex range, offering maximum absorbency for prolonged wear. Great for overnight or high-output situations — without compromising skin health.
Best for:
Severe incontinence, overnight use, or long shifts where changes may be less frequent.
Choose What Works Best for You
Incontinence care isn’t just about managing leaks — it’s about confidence, comfort, and staying active on your own terms. Whether you prefer the independence of pull-up nappies or the custom-fit support of tabbed options, the right product can make everyday life easier.
Still unsure which to pick? That’s okay — we’re here to help.
Need Support Choosing the Right Product?
Our team at Platinum Health Supply Group understands how personal this decision is. Whether you're shopping for yourself, a loved one, or a client, we can guide you through the options and help you find products that suit your needs, lifestyle, and budget.
📍 Visit us in Epping:
Unit 2/51 Trafalgar Road, Epping VIC 3076
Monday to Friday, 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Prefer to shop from home? Explore our full range of discreet, high-quality incontinence care online — with fast shipping Australia-wide.
Browse Incontinence Products Now
Because finding the right support shouldn’t be a struggle. Let’s make it easier, together.
